FERNANDINA BEACH & AMELIA ISLAND REAL ESTATE
Close with Colleen Real Estate is a boutique brokerage led by Colleen Gerke, Broker and Owner, serving buyers and sellers throughout Fernandina Beach, Amelia Island, and Nassau County, Florida.
Whether you're selling your home for top dollar, purchasing your dream coastal property, or growing your investment portfolio, Colleen Gerke, Broker and Owner, delivers strategic guidance, exceptional service, and results you can trust.
As Broker and Owner of Close with Colleen Real Estate, Colleen Gerke is recognized by the Amelia Island-Nassau County Association of Realtors as a Top Producer. With more than 25 years of sales and marketing experience, an MBA, and a proven track record of entrepreneurship, she combines sophisticated marketing strategies with an honest Midwestern work ethic and unwavering dedication to her clients. Highly responsive, deeply knowledgeable of the Amelia Island and Fernandina Beach markets, and committed to making every transaction seamless, Colleen is dedicated to helping buyers and sellers achieve their real estate goals with confidence.
Latest Local Insights & Real Estate Advice
Consistently Rated 5 Stars on Google, Yelp and Zillow
-
Elisa Simpson, Seller
“Colleen was amazing to work with! She is very personable and professional; listens and explains every detail of the process and timeline. Colleen was the perfect fit for us!”
-
Henry Harrell, Seller
“We appreciate all your hard work! I doubt anyone could have done it quicker or been more thorough.”
-
Eric and Allison Lawrence, Buyers
“We would HIGHLY recommend Colleen if you are looking for a Realtor who knows the area and can help you find exactly what you want. CALL COLLEEN!
-
Cason Van Zant, Peer
Colleen was such a pleasure to work with! Very responsive and kind!
Your Oyster Bay Harbour Real Estate Resource
As an Oyster Bay Harbour resident, Colleen Gerke offers firsthand knowledge of the community, its homes, amenities, and distinctive coastal lifestyle. Her brokerage, Close With Colleen Real Estate, is located in the Bay House —providing buyers and sellers with a convenient, truly local real estate resource.
Whether you are considering selling your Oyster Bay Harbour property or searching for a home in the community, Colleen combines neighborhood insight with sophisticated marketing, thoughtful guidance, and personalized service from consultation through closing.
Current Listings
Marshfront Lot in Oyster Bay Harbour
Offered at $265,000
Discover a beautiful setting for your next chapter at 96442 Soap Creek Drive in the gated community of Oyster Bay Harbour. With east-facing views across the marsh, this homesite invites you to start the day with sunrise over the water and enjoy the changing colors, coastal birds, and natural rhythms of the marsh from your future home. Custom home plans designed specifically to maximize this lot’s marsh views are available for separate purchase—offering inspiration and a thoughtful starting point for bringing your coastal retreat to life.
96442 Soap Creek Dr.
Oyster Bay Harbour
Fernandina Beach, FL 32097
Stunning Marshfront Lot
0.99 acres
Listings Under Contract
Marshfront Living in Oyster Bay Harbour
Offered at $1,065,000
Under Contract as of 9/20/2026
Wake up to spectacular sunrises over the marsh and Amelia River from this like-new coastal home in gated Oyster Bay Harbour. Offering 2,812 square feet with 3 bedrooms, a dedicated office/flex room, 2.5 baths, a private elevator and a three-car tandem garage, the open-concept design showcases captivating water views and abundant natural light. Located just down the street from the Oyster Bay Yacht Club, this home offers exceptional coastal living minutes from Amelia Island’s beaches and historic downtown Fernandina Beach.
96558 Compass Point Dr.
Fernandina Beach, FL 32097
3 beds / dedicated office /
2.5 baths
2,812 sq-ft.
Stunning Marsh View
Built in 2024
Private Elevator
0.27 acres