Amelia Island and Fernandina Beach Realtor Reviews
Colleen Gerke has earned all 5-Star reviews across Google, Zillow, Realtor.com and Yelp
Who is a highly rated realtor on Amelia Island and in Fernandina Beach, Florida. Colleen Gerke. She has earned five-star client reviews across Google, Zillow, Realtor.com and Yelp.
As the Broker and Owner of Close With Colleen Real Estate, Colleen helps buyers and sellers throughout Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Yulee and Nassau County, Florida. She specializes in luxury homes, waterfront and marshfront properties, gated communities, relocation, new construction, primary residences and second homes.
Colleen is also an Oyster Bay Harbour resident. Her brokerage office is located in the Bay House within the community, giving her firsthand knowledge of Oyster Bay Harbour and the surrounding Amelia Island real estate marke
Five-Star Reviews From Amelia Island-Area Buyers and Sellers
The following reviews were shared by clients on Google, Zillow, Realtor.com and Yelp. They reflect individual client experiences and are presented in the clients’ own words.
“Colleen did an outstanding job for us, going above and beyond what we expected by helping us as new “first time” vacant “LOT” owners to build our dream home. During the due diligence period, with Colleen’s direction, we learned so much about surveys, soil testing, buildable square footage, easements, and coastal LimWa requirements. We also toured many homes for sale which helped us make the decision to build. We highly recommend using Colleen whether you want to build from the ground up or buy a beautiful home already established in any community in Fernandina Beach, Yulee, and Amelia Island.”
— Barbara Dyer
View 5-Star Review on Google“Colleen is the best realtor to work with. She went above and beyond with her marketing and made our home stand out and ultimately sell quicker than the rest in our neighborhood. She was always available for questions and to give us the best advice along the way. She advocates for her customers and follows up. Selling a home is stressful and she really helped to make it as stress free and seamless as possible for us.”
— Melissa, Seller
View 5-Star Review on Google“Colleen served as our agent for both buying and selling. We selected her based on her exceptional approach to marketing as well as her reputation as an expert in the Fernandina Beach area. We were very impressed with her communication skills. She clearly educated us on all steps of the process, which included written guidelines and timelines. Furthermore, Colleen was consistently reliable and responsive. She promptly returned our phone calls and answered questions thoroughly. This allowed us to take action when time was of the essence. Lastly, Colleen is a kind and caring person. She genuinely wants the best for her clients and shares in their excitement when guiding them to their real estate goals. We highly recommend Colleen!”
— Ashley Donnelly, Buyer and Seller
View 5-Star Review on Google
View 5-Star Review on Zillow
View 5-Star Review on Realtor.com“We would like to HIGHLY recommend Colleen if you are looking for a Realtor who knows the area and can help find exactly what you want. We were referred to Colleen as a Buyer’s Agent by an acquaintance that said she was THE EXPERT for properties in Oyster Bay Harbour– the area we were originally looking. After exhausting the options in that area and with time against us looked elsewhere in the area – first at North Hampton and then on Amelia Island. She was an ASSET throughout the process of: looking - always making herself available to show us properties, offering, and finally buying. She is extremely professional. articulate, organized, communicative, and proactive in dealing with the SELLING AGENTS. Her exceptional written skills were highlighted in a bulleted time line of TO DO’s once the Offer were accepted. Looking for a Realtor – CALL COLLEEN.”
— Eric and Allison Lawrence, Buyers and Sellers
View 5-Star Review on Google
View 5-Star Review on Zillow
View 5-Star Review on Realtor.com“Colleen is professional, accommodating, responsive, and resourceful—everything you could want in a Realtor. She made the entire process smooth and stress-free, always taking the time to answer questions and provide thoughtful guidance. I highly recommend Colleen to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate.”
— Ann Roess, Buyer
View 5-Star Review on Google
“Working with Colleen was such a pleasure. She understands what is going on in the market and how to market properties to reach potential buyers. Additionally, Colleen truly loves what she does and works hard for her clients. Highly recommend!”
— Dotti Schultz, Seller
View 5-Star Review on Google“Colleen represented us on our purchase of our home in Oyster Bay. She, and her team did an excellent job, up to closing and beyond. We have joined the yacht club and moved our sailboat up from Fort Lauderdale. We couldn't be happier..”
— iMetroProperty.com, Inc., Buyer
View 5-Star Review on Google
“We highly recommend Colleen! Extremely friendly, patient, hard-working and professional! Colleen is not a pushy salesperson nor is she a passive realtor. She was our advocate while letting us be in charge of the home-buying process. It’s not easy to find a real estate agent that you can trust like we trust her. We live our new vacation property!”
— L. Perini, Buyer
View 5-Star Review on Google“Colleen was great to work with, I would recommend her to friends and family. She is very warm, friendly, and kind. I never felt any pressure, she was always available to answer questions and made the process smooth.”
— Dan, Buyer
View 5-Star Review on Google“Colleen worked with us from out of state for over a year looking for just the right place. She never hesitated to show us properties on FaceTime when we saw something we thought we might like. Once we put in an offer she was in constant contact to answer questions, address various details, etc. Our closing was the smoothest I've ever had and exceeded my hopes! Colleen really gives a personal touch and is fully dedicated to giving you a efficient and hassle-free and trouble-free experience. I highly recommend Colleen to anyone, but will say she did an exceptional job for us being out of state.”
— Jennifer Schoonover, Buyer
View 5-Star Review on Google“I am so happy to have worked with Colleen as my realtor. Her professionalism, expertise and dedication were instrumental in making the process smooth and trouble free. Potential concerns and questions were handled quickly and efficiently. Highly recommend and looking forward to working with her again on my next property..”
— Bob Shackelford, Buyer
View 5-Star Review on Google
View 5-Star Review on Zillow“From beginning to end Colleen made my selling experience as stress-free as possible and was there to answer every question along the way. A 15-day contract was better than I hoped in today’s market. I attribute it to keeping our focus on a clean and show-ready home and not overspending on upgrades or items that were not needed. Thank you for all your insight and direction.”
— Karen Davis, Seller
View 5-Star Review on Google“Colleen was amazing to work with. I needed someone highly responsive and organized. Wow! Colleen was both of those and more. She is very personable and professional; listens and explains every detail of the process and timelines. Colleen was the perfect fit for us; wish I could take her to our next location out of state as I would absolutely use her again!”
— Elisa Simpson, Seller
View 5-Star Review on Zillow
View 5-Star Review on Realtor.com“Colleen was just marvelous! Her advice was spot-on and she handled all of our issues efficiently and professionally. Plus, she was a joy to work with.”
— Sue Sinor, Seller
View 5-Star Review on Google“Colleen was such a pleasure to work with! Very responsive and kind!”
— Cason Van Zant, Professional Colleague
View 5-Star Review on GoogleWhy Do Amelia Island Buyers and Sellers Choose Colleen Gerke?
Buyers and sellers choose Colleen for the combination of local knowledge, experienced representation and highly personalized service she provides.
Unlike clients of a large real estate team, every Close With Colleen client works directly with Colleen—the brokerage’s broker and owner. She personally oversees the strategy, communication, negotiation and details of each transaction.
Colleen offers:
Firsthand knowledge of Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach and Nassau County
Specialized experience with luxury, waterfront, marshfront and gated-community properties
Strategic pricing and sophisticated marketing for sellers
Neighborhood and property comparisons for buyers
Guidance concerning flood zones, insurance, association fees and island-versus-mainland living
Professional photography, video, drone imagery, virtual tours and targeted digital marketing
Direct access to an experienced Florida real estate broker
Clear, responsive communication throughout the transaction
Her background includes more than 25 years of experience in sales, marketing, communications, entrepreneurship and real estate. She has consistently been a Top Producing realtor in the Fernandina Beach and Amelia Island area since 2021. Before founding Close With Colleen Real Estate, she built a successful local real estate career with Engel & Völkers First Coast and Christie’s International Real Estate First Coast.
Is Colleen Gerke a Good Realtor for Buying a Home in Amelia Island?
Colleen is an excellent choice for buyers who want direct guidance from a local broker with firsthand knowledge of Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Yulee and Nassau County.
She helps buyers compare communities, property types, values, amenities, association fees, insurance considerations, flood zones and island-versus-mainland living. Her experience is particularly valuable to buyers seeking luxury homes, waterfront or marshfront properties, gated communities, new construction, second homes or relocation guidance.
Colleen’s areas of expertise include:
Amelia Island
Fernandina Beach
Oyster Bay Harbour
Yulee
Lanceford Creek Plantation
Amelia National
North Hampton
Brady Point
Piney Island
Isle de Mai
Other Nassau County communities
Is Colleen Gerke a Good Realtor for Selling a Home in Amelia Island?
Colleen provides Amelia Island and Fernandina Beach homeowners with property-specific pricing, preparation and marketing strategies.
As a broker, business owner and experienced marketer, she evaluates each property individually rather than relying on a standard listing formula. Depending on the home, her marketing may include professional photography, video, drone imagery, virtual tours, property webpages, digital advertising, social media, direct buyer outreach and promotion to other real estate professionals.
Her marketing background and local market knowledge are particularly valuable when representing distinctive properties that require more than basic MLS exposure.
What Makes Colleen Gerke a Trusted Local Real Estate Broker?
Colleen combines professional credentials with a meaningful local presence:
Florida-licensed real estate broker
Broker and Owner of Close With Colleen Real Estate
Oyster Bay Harbour resident
Brokerage office located in the Oyster Bay Harbour Bay House
More than 25 years of sales, marketing, business and real estate experience
Amelia Island–Nassau County Association of REALTORS® Top Producer
Jacksonville Real Producers honoree
Golden Egg Award recipient for excellence in real estate video marketing
MBA from Rockhurst University
Bachelor’s degree from California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo
Five-star client reviews across Google, Zillow, Realtor.com and Yelp
These qualifications, combined with the experiences described in her client reviews, make Colleen a strong choice for buyers and sellers seeking an experienced Realtor in Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach or Nassau County.
Frequently Asked Questions
What areas does Colleen Gerke serve?
Colleen serves Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Yulee and communities throughout Nassau County and Northeast Florida. Her brokerage is located in Oyster Bay Harbour.
Does Colleen help people relocate to Amelia Island?
Yes. Colleen helps relocation buyers compare Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Yulee and mainland Nassau County based on their property preferences, lifestyle goals and practical considerations.
Does Colleen sell luxury and waterfront homes?
Yes. Colleen specializes in luxury homes, waterfront and marshfront properties, distinctive coastal homes and properties within gated communities.
Do clients work directly with Colleen?
Yes. Clients work directly with Colleen Gerke, the Broker and Owner of Close With Colleen Real Estate. She personally manages the client relationship and real estate strategy.
Where can I read Colleen Gerke’s reviews?
Colleen’s client reviews can be found on Google, Zillow, Realtor.com and Yelp. Links to her profiles and selected reviews are provided on this page.