Buying a Second Home in Florida? Understand the 5% Assessment Cap

How does Florida’s new 5% assessment cap affect buyers of second homes?

Beginning January 1, 2027, Amendment 3 lowers the annual assessment cap from 10% to 5% for qualifying non-homestead property, including many second homes, for taxes other than school district levies. After a sale, the property generally resets to just value on the next January 1. For your purchase budget, start with an estimate based on the new ownership.

If you’re shopping for a second home on Amelia Island, you’ll likely see the seller’s annual property taxes in the listing. That figure can help you understand the property’s history. I’d still run a fresh estimate before deciding what the home will cost you to own, especially if the seller has owned it for years.

What the 5% cap applies to

A vacation home that isn’t your permanent residence is generally treated as non-homestead property. Under Florida Amendment 3, the assessment used for non-school property taxes on qualifying properties can generally rise by no more than 5% annually after the cap applies. School district levies are calculated separately. A change in ownership or certain improvements can also affect the assessment.

Three numbers help make sense of the county record. Just value is the appraiser’s estimate of market value. Assessed value reflects any assessment limits that apply. Taxable value is what remains after applicable exemptions and is the figure used with the tax rate to calculate a levy. A single property can show different taxable values for school and non-school taxes.

Your bill also reflects rates set by the taxing authorities and may include separate assessments or charges. So a 5% limit on one part of the calculation can still produce a different percentage change in the bill you actually pay.

What changes after you close

The Nassau County Property Appraiser explains that a change in ownership typically removes the previous owner’s exemptions and caps and resets the assessed value to market value on January 1 after the purchase. If a seller’s assessment had been held down for years, the difference can be substantial. This can apply even if both you and the seller use the property as a second home.

For example, imagine a Fernandina Beach property with a current non-school assessed value of $650,000. If you buy it and the county sets its just value at $900,000 on the following January 1, that $900,000 is the starting point in this example. The prior owner’s $650,000 assessment does not become the base for your 5% cap.

If just value rises to $980,000 the next year, a 5% cap on that $900,000 base would limit the non-school assessed value to $945,000, assuming the cap applies and there are no other adjustments. Those figures illustrate the assessment calculation. The tax bill would still depend on the rates and charges for that parcel. Your purchase price can help you estimate costs, but the county determines just value.

Build a post-closing tax estimate before you make an offer

  1. Look up the parcel. Pull the property record and current tax bill. Note the just value, the school and non-school taxable values, and any exemptions shown for the seller.

  2. Run an estimate using your expected purchase price. Use the tax estimator on the Nassau County Property Appraiser’s site as a starting point. Model the home as non-homestead if you expect to use it as a second home. Confirm how the estimate treats separate charges.

  3. Check the taxing district. Two homes with similar prices can have different tax bills. A home inside Fernandina Beach city limits and one in unincorporated Nassau County can be subject to different levies. Check the specific parcel even when both listings show a Fernandina Beach mailing address.

  4. Use your estimate in the ownership budget. Put it alongside your insurance quotes, association or condo dues, and expected maintenance. If you’re financing the purchase, ask your lender which tax figure it used to calculate the escrow payment.

Closing late in the year? The tax amount used for proration at closing and the bill you receive after the next assessment can be based on different tax years. Ask your closing agent which figure they are using at settlement, and use your post-purchase estimate for your ongoing budget.

If you’re comparing second homes on Amelia Island, in Fernandina Beach or elsewhere in Nassau County, I’m happy to help you find the parcel records and work through the questions to ask before you make an offer. Reach out at CloseWithColleen.com.

About the Author

Colleen Gerke is the Broker and Owner of Close with Colleen Real Estate, a boutique real estate brokerage serving home buyers and sellers throughout Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Yulee and Nassau County, Florida. As an Oyster Bay Harbour resident with a brokerage office located within the community, Colleen combines firsthand local knowledge with more than 20 years of sales and marketing experience to help clients confidently buy and sell coastal, luxury, waterfront and residential properties. To explore Amelia Island–area homes for sale, request a personalized home valuation or visit www.CloseWithColleen.com.

Next
Next

What Is Taxable Value in Florida After Amendment 3?